Login

 

 

The Fallacy of Teamwork Part II: Michael Jordan Doesn’t Need a Memo


In my continuing critique of the notorious practice of applying team-sports models to
business work it is useful to ask what neuroscience has to say on the subject.


147352337-400x237The tool that makes all teamwork possible is communication. Neuroscience and brain imaging studies make it clear that the kind of communication that occurs in sports differs profoundly from the kind that occurs with symbolic thought used in business projects. (1). The buddy who watches your back on the battlefield doesn’t need a memo to figure out what to do if there is an incoming RPG. There may be only a few seconds to react. Training, instinct and reflexes kick in, exactly as they do on the basketball court or the soccer field.


The language which facilitates physical skill focuses on spatial-temporal reasoning, not symbolic thought or language. Michael Jordan doesn’t need a memo either. This language has a several million year head start over human language, which has been around for only 100,000 years. (2 & 3).


Athletes use a different and older language than employees collaborating on a business memo. The units of information exchanged differ and the way the information is processed in the brain differs. Symbolic thought would slow down basketball players while the spatial reasoning skills involved in passing the ball are useless to workers drafting a memo.


Collaborative projects of any kind require the following questions to be answered: Who does what, when, where, and how? These are real questions (the “five friends” of poet and author Rudyard Kipling) that must be answered by real people accepting real responsibility. The error of reification, of thinking that ‘the team will write the memo’ is always invoked whenever the word ‘team‘ is used this way.


For collaborative mental labor the subjects to be charged with responsibility better have a pulse and a brain. In this sense teams don’t even exist: There is no such thing as a team. This is why I prefer the word ‘collaborate’ over teamwork. The word ‘team’ is semantically inadequate.


BrainWorking350But there is one special kind of teamwork that is better than any other and uses a language that evolved in vertebrates many hundreds of millions of years ago - this is the interactions that occur between neurons inside the brain. Brain cells communicate with one another very well. Communication between people is slower and always more difficult than thinking. The greatest teamwork in the world is what goes on inside our own heads.


What if the neurons inside the brain communicated with one another with exactly the same degree of efficiency as human communication? Such a brain would be a disaster. Conversely, what if workers  collaborating on a project could communicate with exactly the same degree of efficiency as neurons talking to each other inside the brain? This is an unknown ideal of teamwork, and we are very, very far from it.


Perhaps for these reasons the highest levels of human achievement in fields requiring symbolic thought are dominated by individuals, not teams. Human communication and the collaboration which depends on it has a long way to go to catch up with the speed of thought. The silent and instinctive language spoken by athletes is no help with business projects.

Think Outside The Box

In order to think outside the box you must first step out of the box!


See:
(1) http://www.jneurosci.org/cgi/content/full/23/10/3959
(2) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_language
(3) http://www.genling.nw.ru/Staff/Psycholinguistics/Precis.pdf

 

LEGAL DISCLAIMER

George Adams
Certified Public Accountant Master of Business Administration
Tel: (207) 989-2700 E-Mail: GeorgeAdams@IntelligenceForRent.com
450 South Main Street: The HQ of IQ
Brewer, Maine 04412-2339

©2015 Copyright George Adams CPA MBA. All Rights Reserved.

 

Why Switch Accountants

02-29-2012 Hits:7009 Services George Adams

Why Switch Accountants

WHY SWITCH ACCOUNTANTS? You Have Nothing To Lose: • Free Initial Consultation • Free Review Of Prior Year Tax Returns • No Obligation Of Any Kind You Have Everything...

Read more

Saving Money With S Corporations

09-25-2011 Hits:12333 Services George Adams

Saving Money With S Corporations

Smart = S Corporation = $ In GeneralS Corporations are an under-used opportunity available to most small Maine family businesses as a way to gain control over taxes. I...

Read more

Business Consulting

09-28-2011 Hits:9889 Services George Adams

Business Consulting

“The great problems of the world require a great love to achieve their solution. Many people wait until the fire alarm goes off before seeking professional advice.

Read more

Code Of Ethics

09-24-2011 Hits:8514 Services George Adams

Code Of Ethics

These are the equitable principles which govern my business: I will help every client pay the legal minimum tax, and not one cent more.

Read more

Proof of Intelligence

09-23-2011 Hits:13616 Services George Adams

Proof of Intelligence

Character and intelligence are the two vital attributes required of business professionals. The successful application of character and intelligence in the real world earns the most meaningful form of...

Read more

Asset Protection and Anonymity Services

09-25-2011 Hits:8868 Services George Adams

Asset Protection and Anonymity Services

If you own nothing then nothing can be taken from you. Legally owning nothing is the strategy discussed in important books like

Read more

Non-Profits

09-25-2011 Hits:8592 Services George Adams

Non-Profits

There Is No Such Thing as a Non-ProfitI’ve always been amused by the term “non-profit.” In accounting and tax terms it refers to an organization the primary purpose of...

Read more

Business Appraisals

09-25-2011 Hits:8430 Services George Adams

Business Appraisals

Vision and ValueMost appraisers stare through a pinhole when they view and value a business. Their vision is limited to very few pre-defined criteria that help them complete pre-defined...

Read more

Business and Personal Tax Preparation Services

09-24-2011 Hits:8867 Services George Adams

Business and Personal Tax Preparation Services

Forewarned Is ForearmedMost people think tax returns are just about taxes. This is wrong. In fact there are two very important numbers in every tax return. The first is obvious...

Read more

Audits, Reviews, Compilations and Fraud/Theft Detection

09-24-2011 Hits:10747 Services George Adams

Audits, Reviews, Compilations and Fraud/Theft Detection

My Experience I have many years of experience with audits, reviews and compilations for both business and non-profit entities. Audits require significant planning in order to achieve a successful engagement.

Read more

How Can You Help Yourself

09-23-2011 Hits:9128 Services George Adams

How Can You Help Yourself

It is a mistake to believe a CPA can do your thinking for you. In the context of your business, you are irreplaceable. You as a decision maker, owner,...

Read more

Current Service Fees

09-24-2011 Hits:10692 Services George Adams

Current Service Fees

Why I Do Not Bill By The Hour Most CPA firms bill clients by the hour. This practice imposes administrative and bureaucratic inefficiencies typical of companies that are too...

Read more

How I Can Help You

09-23-2011 Hits:10542 Services George Adams

How I Can Help You

The efficient and effective use of intelligence saves money, reduces taxes, prevents companies from jumping off a cliff and, in general, makes life easier and better by identifying risks...

Read more

Bookkeeping

09-25-2011 Hits:8808 Services George Adams

Bookkeeping

The Importance of Being RightBookkeeping is the bread and butter of accounting. Taxes deal with the totality of your accounting system on one day of the year

Read more

 

Contact Me

Member

Telephone: (207) 989-2700
Fax: 1-866-444-0032
Email - georgeadams@intelligenceforrent.com
Address: 450 South Main Street: The HQ of IQ
               Brewer Maine 04412-2339

Maine Society of Certified Public Accountants
Certified QuickBooks Professional Advisor
Bangor Region Chamber of Commerce
Beta Gamma Sigma and Phi Kappa Phi
National Association of Independent Writers and Editors
Published Contributing Writer-Maine Eagle Magazine
New England Peer Review

 

© 2017 Copyright George Adams CPA MBA. All Rights Reserved.
George Adams - More Than Just a CPASM